Skip to content

Evaluating tech's role in behaviour modification

I discuss a road crossing screen in China that publicly shames jaywalkers, and why that kind of real time identification would feel authoritarian in Western contexts. I also consider how workplace screens could respond to unsafe behaviour in a more constructive way, using safety reminders rather than naming and shaming.

Key takeaways

  • Public shaming through screens can cross ethical and cultural boundaries.
  • Real time observation of unsafe behaviour could help adjust safety messaging.
  • Constructive prompts are more useful than exposing individuals or making them defensive.

Topics

  • Technology
  • Innovation
  • Company Culture

Transcript

Sometimes technology takes things a little too far. So I saw a recent post on X about how a Chinese screen implementation was working on a busy road crossing. Effectively, if pedestrians were jaywalking, the screen showed pictures of them and shamed them in a way of maybe getting them to conform to more safe behaviour. Now, I think it's pretty obvious that that is way overstepping the mark, and most people would find this authoritarian and creepy. It doesn't matter so much in China, but it certainly would matter in the West. However, beyond obviously just saying that that feels wrong, there is something in this as an idea. If you are in real time observing unsafe behaviour, say in a workplace, that could and should influence the content that goes up on screen. Now, naming and shaming might not actually be that productive in terms of helping people. It might even make them double down. But what if you could see that people were, for example, regularly not putting on health and safety goggles and hats, and that started to influence a higher frequency of explanations as to why this was the right thing to do, to try and influence that behaviour back in. So obviously, I'm going to give this a very low zero out of five score for the implementation. But in terms of the idea and how this could be better implemented, I will give it a three. And if I saw a good implementation, I would give a four or a five. So that's my signs of genius score. Let me know in the comments what you think.